ojs2 has produced an error Message: USER NOTICE: Deprecated import of a partially qualified class name. In file: /home/neuroqua/public_html/lib/pkp/includes/functions.inc.php At line: 34 Stacktrace: File: (unknown) line (unknown) Function: PKPApplication->errorHandler(1024, "Deprecated import of a partially qualified class name.", "/home/neuroqua/public_html/lib/pkp/includes/functions.inc.php", 34, Array(3)) File: /home/neuroqua/public_html/lib/pkp/includes/functions.inc.php line 34 Function: trigger_error("Deprecated import of a partially qualified class name.") File: /home/neuroqua/public_html/plugins/generic/reviewerIndex/ReviewerIndexPlugin.inc.php line 14 Function: import("classes.plugins.GenericPlugin") File: /home/neuroqua/public_html/plugins/generic/reviewerIndex/index.php line 18 Function: require_once("/home/neuroqua/public_html/plugins/generic/reviewerIndex/ReviewerIndexPlugin.inc.php") File: /home/neuroqua/public_html/lib/pkp/classes/plugins/PluginRegistry.inc.php line 221 Function: include("/home/neuroqua/public_html/plugins/generic/reviewerIndex/index.php") File: /home/neuroqua/public_html/lib/pkp/classes/plugins/PluginRegistry.inc.php line 107 Function: PluginRegistry->_instantiatePlugin("generic", "plugins/generic", "reviewerIndex", "ReviewerIndexPlugin") File: /home/neuroqua/public_html/lib/pkp/classes/core/Dispatcher.inc.php line 131 Function: PluginRegistry->loadCategory("generic", True) File: /home/neuroqua/public_html/lib/pkp/classes/core/PKPApplication.inc.php line 189 Function: Dispatcher->dispatch(Object(Request)) File: /home/neuroqua/public_html/index.php line 63 Function: PKPApplication->execute() Server info: OS: Linux PHP Version: 5.6.40 Apache Version: N/A DB Driver: mysqli DB server version: 10.2.27-MariaDB-cll-lve
ojs2 has produced an error Message: USER NOTICE: Deprecated function. In file: /home/neuroqua/public_html/classes/journal/Journal.inc.php At line: 259 Stacktrace: File: (unknown) line (unknown) Function: PKPApplication->errorHandler(1024, "Deprecated function.", "/home/neuroqua/public_html/classes/journal/Journal.inc.php", 259, Array(0)) File: /home/neuroqua/public_html/classes/journal/Journal.inc.php line 259 Function: trigger_error("Deprecated function.") File: /home/neuroqua/public_html/plugins/generic/reviewerIndex/ReviewerIndexPlugin.inc.php line 96 Function: Journal->getJournalId() File: /home/neuroqua/public_html/plugins/generic/reviewerIndex/ReviewerIndexPlugin.inc.php line 49 Function: ReviewerIndexPlugin->getEnabled() File: /home/neuroqua/public_html/lib/pkp/classes/plugins/PluginRegistry.inc.php line 65 Function: ReviewerIndexPlugin->register("generic", "plugins/generic/reviewerIndex") File: /home/neuroqua/public_html/lib/pkp/classes/plugins/PluginRegistry.inc.php line 136 Function: PluginRegistry->register("generic", Object(ReviewerIndexPlugin), "plugins/generic/reviewerIndex") File: /home/neuroqua/public_html/lib/pkp/classes/core/Dispatcher.inc.php line 131 Function: PluginRegistry->loadCategory("generic", True) File: /home/neuroqua/public_html/lib/pkp/classes/core/PKPApplication.inc.php line 189 Function: Dispatcher->dispatch(Object(Request)) File: /home/neuroqua/public_html/index.php line 63 Function: PKPApplication->execute() Server info: OS: Linux PHP Version: 5.6.40 Apache Version: N/A DB Driver: mysqli DB server version: 10.2.27-MariaDB-cll-lve
ojs2 has produced an error Message: USER NOTICE: Deprecated function. In file: /home/neuroqua/public_html/classes/article/Article.inc.php At line: 70 Stacktrace: File: (unknown) line (unknown) Function: PKPApplication->errorHandler(1024, "Deprecated function.", "/home/neuroqua/public_html/classes/article/Article.inc.php", 70, Array(0)) File: /home/neuroqua/public_html/classes/article/Article.inc.php line 70 Function: trigger_error("Deprecated function.") File: /home/neuroqua/public_html/pages/article/ArticleHandler.inc.php line 208 Function: Article->getArticleTitle() File: (unknown) line (unknown) Function: ArticleHandler->view(Array(2), Object(Request)) File: /home/neuroqua/public_html/lib/pkp/classes/core/PKPRouter.inc.php line 370 Function: call_user_func(Array(2), Array(2), Object(Request)) File: /home/neuroqua/public_html/lib/pkp/classes/core/PKPPageRouter.inc.php line 266 Function: PKPRouter->_authorizeInitializeAndCallRequest(Array(2), Object(Request), Array(2), False) File: /home/neuroqua/public_html/lib/pkp/classes/core/Dispatcher.inc.php line 133 Function: PKPPageRouter->route(Object(Request)) File: /home/neuroqua/public_html/lib/pkp/classes/core/PKPApplication.inc.php line 189 Function: Dispatcher->dispatch(Object(Request)) File: /home/neuroqua/public_html/index.php line 63 Function: PKPApplication->execute() Server info: OS: Linux PHP Version: 5.6.40 Apache Version: N/A DB Driver: mysqli DB server version: 10.2.27-MariaDB-cll-lve
ojs2 has produced an error Message: WARNING: Cannot modify header information - headers already sent by (output started at /home/neuroqua/public_html/lib/pkp/classes/core/PKPApplication.inc.php:392) In file: /home/neuroqua/public_html/lib/pkp/classes/template/PKPTemplateManager.inc.php At line: 339 Stacktrace: File: (unknown) line (unknown) Function: PKPApplication->errorHandler(2, "Cannot modify header information - headers already sent by (output started at /home/neuroqua/public_html/lib/pkp/classes/core/PKPApplication.inc.php:392)", "/home/neuroqua/public_html/lib/pkp/classes/template/PKPTemplateManager.inc.php", 339, Array(7)) File: /home/neuroqua/public_html/lib/pkp/classes/template/PKPTemplateManager.inc.php line 339 Function: header("Content-Type: text/html; charset=utf-8") File: /home/neuroqua/public_html/pages/article/ArticleHandler.inc.php line 235 Function: PKPTemplateManager->display("article/article.tpl") File: (unknown) line (unknown) Function: ArticleHandler->view(Array(2), Object(Request)) File: /home/neuroqua/public_html/lib/pkp/classes/core/PKPRouter.inc.php line 370 Function: call_user_func(Array(2), Array(2), Object(Request)) File: /home/neuroqua/public_html/lib/pkp/classes/core/PKPPageRouter.inc.php line 266 Function: PKPRouter->_authorizeInitializeAndCallRequest(Array(2), Object(Request), Array(2), False) File: /home/neuroqua/public_html/lib/pkp/classes/core/Dispatcher.inc.php line 133 Function: PKPPageRouter->route(Object(Request)) File: /home/neuroqua/public_html/lib/pkp/classes/core/PKPApplication.inc.php line 189 Function: Dispatcher->dispatch(Object(Request)) File: /home/neuroqua/public_html/index.php line 63 Function: PKPApplication->execute() Server info: OS: Linux PHP Version: 5.6.40 Apache Version: N/A DB Driver: mysqli DB server version: 10.2.27-MariaDB-cll-lve
ojs2 has produced an error Message: WARNING: Cannot modify header information - headers already sent by (output started at /home/neuroqua/public_html/lib/pkp/classes/core/PKPApplication.inc.php:392) In file: /home/neuroqua/public_html/lib/pkp/classes/template/PKPTemplateManager.inc.php At line: 342 Stacktrace: File: (unknown) line (unknown) Function: PKPApplication->errorHandler(2, "Cannot modify header information - headers already sent by (output started at /home/neuroqua/public_html/lib/pkp/classes/core/PKPApplication.inc.php:392)", "/home/neuroqua/public_html/lib/pkp/classes/template/PKPTemplateManager.inc.php", 342, Array(7)) File: /home/neuroqua/public_html/lib/pkp/classes/template/PKPTemplateManager.inc.php line 342 Function: header("Cache-Control: no-store") File: /home/neuroqua/public_html/pages/article/ArticleHandler.inc.php line 235 Function: PKPTemplateManager->display("article/article.tpl") File: (unknown) line (unknown) Function: ArticleHandler->view(Array(2), Object(Request)) File: /home/neuroqua/public_html/lib/pkp/classes/core/PKPRouter.inc.php line 370 Function: call_user_func(Array(2), Array(2), Object(Request)) File: /home/neuroqua/public_html/lib/pkp/classes/core/PKPPageRouter.inc.php line 266 Function: PKPRouter->_authorizeInitializeAndCallRequest(Array(2), Object(Request), Array(2), False) File: /home/neuroqua/public_html/lib/pkp/classes/core/Dispatcher.inc.php line 133 Function: PKPPageRouter->route(Object(Request)) File: /home/neuroqua/public_html/lib/pkp/classes/core/PKPApplication.inc.php line 189 Function: Dispatcher->dispatch(Object(Request)) File: /home/neuroqua/public_html/index.php line 63 Function: PKPApplication->execute() Server info: OS: Linux PHP Version: 5.6.40 Apache Version: N/A DB Driver: mysqli DB server version: 10.2.27-MariaDB-cll-lve
Why Jaegwon Kim’s Physicalism is Not Near Enough: An Implicit Argument for a non-Cartesian Interactionism (Part I) | Scharf | NeuroQuantology


DOI: 10.14704/nq.2010.8.3.330

Why Jaegwon Kim’s Physicalism is Not Near Enough: An Implicit Argument for a non-Cartesian Interactionism (Part I)

David Scharf

Abstract


Kim’s argument for a minimal physicalism breaks down in two critical places. First, his functional reduction of cognitive/intentional properties fails to do justice to what we mean when we refer to belief, desire and the like, because it fails to account for their referential and normative content. And although Kim believes that he is saving what is distinctive about our cognitive/intentional life, by providing for mental causation in the context of functional reduction, it can be shown that mental causation without autonomy is inadequate, and irredeemably so, as Davidson anticipated. Thus Kim saves mental causation in name only. Although Kim has famously and, I believe, successfully critiqued Davidson’s solution to the problem of mental autonomy in terms of nonreductive physicalism, Kim has never adequately addressed Davidson’s motivation. Second, his minimal physicalism depends on a metaphysically fundamental partition between phenomenal consciousness and cognitive/intentional properties. This idea cannot be made coherent, because consciousness itself is intrinsically cognitive. This second argument will be developed in Part II. In introducing Part I, we will explain a crucial ambiguity in Kim’s principle of the causal closure of the physical. By failing to appreciate the importance of this ambiguity, Kim’s strong version of causal closure, which is anything but innocuous, is misleadingly made to appear so. In effect, Kim’s under-appreciation of the complexity of the closure principle leads him to attack a straw man—in the form of an outmoded conception of immaterial minds—and ignore the possibility of an interactionism involving quantum neuroscience.

Keywords


Jaegwon Kim; physicalism; supervenience; interactionism; philosophy of mind; functional reduction; eliminative materialism; Donald Davidson; William James

Full Text:

PDF

Supporting Agencies



ojs2 has produced an error Message: USER NOTICE: Deprecated function. In file: /home/neuroqua/public_html/classes/journal/Journal.inc.php At line: 259 Stacktrace: File: (unknown) line (unknown) Function: PKPApplication->errorHandler(1024, "Deprecated function.", "/home/neuroqua/public_html/classes/journal/Journal.inc.php", 259, Array(0)) File: /home/neuroqua/public_html/classes/journal/Journal.inc.php line 259 Function: trigger_error("Deprecated function.") File: /home/neuroqua/public_html/plugins/generic/piwik/PiwikPlugin.inc.php line 167 Function: Journal->getJournalId() File: (unknown) line (unknown) Function: PiwikPlugin->insertFooter("Templates::Article::Footer::PageFooter", Array(3)) File: /home/neuroqua/public_html/lib/pkp/classes/plugins/HookRegistry.inc.php line 83 Function: call_user_func(Array(2), "Templates::Article::Footer::PageFooter", Array(3)) File: /home/neuroqua/public_html/lib/pkp/classes/template/PKPTemplateManager.inc.php line 703 Function: HookRegistry->call("Templates::Article::Footer::PageFooter", Array(3)) File: /home/neuroqua/public_html/cache/t_compile/%%CC^CCB^CCBBF62B%%footer.tpl.php line 55 Function: PKPTemplateManager->smartyCallHook(Array(1), Object(TemplateManager)) File: /home/neuroqua/public_html/lib/pkp/lib/smarty/Smarty.class.php line 1869 Function: include("/home/neuroqua/public_html/cache/t_compile/%%CC^CCB^CCBBF62B%%footer.tpl.php") File: /home/neuroqua/public_html/lib/pkp/classes/template/PKPTemplateManager.inc.php line 210 Function: Smarty->_smarty_include(Array(2)) File: /home/neuroqua/public_html/cache/t_compile/%%38^38D^38D7420B%%article.tpl.php line 182 Function: PKPTemplateManager->_smarty_include(Array(2)) File: /home/neuroqua/public_html/lib/pkp/lib/smarty/Smarty.class.php line 1263 Function: include("/home/neuroqua/public_html/cache/t_compile/%%38^38D^38D7420B%%article.tpl.php") File: /home/neuroqua/public_html/lib/pkp/classes/template/PKPTemplateManager.inc.php line 295 Function: Smarty->fetch("article/article.tpl", Null, Null, True) File: /home/neuroqua/public_html/lib/pkp/classes/template/PKPTemplateManager.inc.php line 346 Function: PKPTemplateManager->fetch("article/article.tpl", Null, Null, True) File: /home/neuroqua/public_html/pages/article/ArticleHandler.inc.php line 235 Function: PKPTemplateManager->display("article/article.tpl") File: (unknown) line (unknown) Function: ArticleHandler->view(Array(2), Object(Request)) File: /home/neuroqua/public_html/lib/pkp/classes/core/PKPRouter.inc.php line 370 Function: call_user_func(Array(2), Array(2), Object(Request)) File: /home/neuroqua/public_html/lib/pkp/classes/core/PKPPageRouter.inc.php line 266 Function: PKPRouter->_authorizeInitializeAndCallRequest(Array(2), Object(Request), Array(2), False) File: /home/neuroqua/public_html/lib/pkp/classes/core/Dispatcher.inc.php line 133 Function: PKPPageRouter->route(Object(Request)) File: /home/neuroqua/public_html/lib/pkp/classes/core/PKPApplication.inc.php line 189 Function: Dispatcher->dispatch(Object(Request)) File: /home/neuroqua/public_html/index.php line 63 Function: PKPApplication->execute() Server info: OS: Linux PHP Version: 5.6.40 Apache Version: N/A DB Driver: mysqli DB server version: 10.2.27-MariaDB-cll-lve


| NeuroScience + QuantumPhysics> NeuroQuantology :: Copyright 2001-2019